Decided to retexture the shield because it didn't feel right at all. I wanted it to feel warn, like it was in a battle, so I started from scratch, and read this tutorial over http://polygonseverywhere.weebly.com/metal-textures-in-games.html.

Front came out nice, but I don't like the back that much. The bronze still looks bleh. Bumped the texture up to 512x512. Should add a normal map for the rivets.